.
Feedback

Updated: Defendants in Makamah Fight Case Out of Jail

All five have either made bail or were released on their own recognizance.

The five defendants just after the new year began have all either been released from jail or made bail, according to county records. were all arrested after allegedly entering a party on Makamah Road hosted by Justin Femiano, 19, just after midnight on New Year's Eve and causing a brawl that left seven injured.


Frank Curra, 22, of Ninth Avenue, East Northport; Thomas Savocchi, 20, and Jacob Savocchi, 18, of Kimberly Drive, East Northport; Victor Smith, 22, of Applegate Drive, Central Islip, and Blaise Felice, 20, of Acre View Drive, Northport were all arrested after allegedly entering a party on Makamah Road hosted by Justin Femiano, 19, just after midnight on New Year's Eve and causing a brawl that left seven injured.

According to various accounts, two or three of the defendants went to the party before midnight on New Year's Eve. They were asked to leave because Femiano's parents, Genevieve and Ken Femiano, were in the city and didn't know about the gathering. Justin reportedly wanted the party to stay low key and end not long after midnight, except for a small group of friends.

Editor's Note: Witnesses have since told Northport Patch that the party was anything but low key. Instead, the house appeared to be full with guests.

After being asked to leave, the men acquiesced, but came back in less than an hour with reinforcements in the form of more people and weapons that included knives, a baseball bat and a pole. 

They knocked on the door and when the door opened slightly they pushed it open and began a brawl. Party guest Zach Atkinson was hit over the head with the bat. Another guest, Arizona Hutchinson, was punched in the face. Rob Oliva, Rob Fallon and Sam Bartig were all stabbed with Oliva getting the worst of it with injuries that required surgery and a weeklong stay at Huntington Hospital. Fallon was also in the hospital for several days. 

Immediately following the fight, another guest took Oliva and Fallon to the hospital. The car in which they rode reportedly passed Suffolk County police as they made their way to the house following a 911 call from one of the guests.

Bartig, Atkinson and Hutchinson went to the hospital in an ambulance after police arrived. The car in which the defendants rode reportedly passed police, too, as they made their way to the house. Police didn't question the defendants until they arrived at Huntington Hospital to seek medical attention for two of their group who had been injured in the fight. 

After interviewing the subjects, police arrested the five men and charged them with one count of burglary of a dwelling causing injury, a class "B" felony, and one count of assault with intent to cause physical injury with a weapon, a class "D" felony. 

Following the arrests,  the defendants were arraigned on New Year's Day and bail was set at $15,000 cash or $30,000 bond except for Victor Smith, whose bail was set at $25,000 cash and $50,000 bond. Temporary orders of protection were issued by the judges in favor of the victims.

 All five were scheduled to return to court last week. At that time, the case was continued as was bail and the orders of protection. 

As of Tuesday, all of the defendants made bail and were released from Suffolk County Jail in Riverhead except for Smith, who was released on his own recognizance.

All are due back in court March 9.

Northport Patch will continue to follow this story.  

Tyson March 21, 2011 at 01:48 am
If the person who is writing all these comments is one of the defendents,you are only making it worse for yourself. If it is a friend, he is making life harder for you and you should tell him to stop. Either way, you can't fight city hall. We all know that.
The best way to be after you screw up is humble. People will forgive you if you are humble.
Justice? March 23, 2011 at 01:17 am
Kelly - why do you allow such nasty comments to stay on this site? Y is it okay for this to remain "But if you don't, I will look for you, I will find you, and I will k--l you " written by Tyson on 1/29? Everyone on this blog sounds mighty angry. I do understand the nature of the case. But everyone is innocent until proven guilty. You can have a comment on the story, but y don't you a better job in filtering these comments? Dont you think this is getting out of hand here? All these comments are horrible. I understand the "story isn't pretty" but that's what it is.... a story. No one knows what actually happened, its a bunch of young adults that reported these actions. How long are you going to let this blog spin out of control? This seems to be like the "Enquirer" its all smut! Where is your posting and advise to the youth and more importantly to parents not to allow these types of parties? Where is your guidance of "what to do when a party gets out of control"? A situation happens you post it and let the animals on here attack each other and do nothing.....what kind of "editor" are you?? You should express feedback here, monitor these posts and encourage positive behavior. Maybe add this at the end of your blog, each time you make an appearance "Innocent until proven guilty".
Kelly Campbell March 23, 2011 at 02:21 am
Justice, I deleted the Jan. 29 post and I truly apologize for not doing so sooner and not monitoring the activity stream as closely as some would like. I am no expert on "what to do when parties get out of control" but did post a letter from the Suffolk County police reviewing the 'social-host law'and have just begun running a local column from the Community Drug and Alcohol Task Force. Perhaps some of the experts from that organization can offer some advice. We also place as much emphasis on kids doing good as we do on crime. We have a column that runs at least weekly called Whiz Kids. I believe in free speech and hashing it out. It's not the editor's job to monitor what people feel or think.
Polly March 23, 2011 at 11:27 am
Oh the irony... personal attacks on you, Kelly, should be deleted, too, IMO.
I know how hard you work and you are doing a great job, Kel!
Kelly Campbell March 23, 2011 at 01:01 pm
I appreciate it, Polly. I always want to strive to improve but will never be perfect. Thanks again.
Formerres March 24, 2011 at 10:34 pm
John, to my knowledge it was a member of the supposed victims party that punched a girl in the face. Could you please post the supporting court documents stating otherwise?
justice? March 25, 2011 at 02:40 am
Kelly, I don't believe its your job to monitor what people feel or think, I do think its your job to monitor some of the inappropriate behavior that is written on this blog? Seems to be, all these post are for revenge from both parties and this is a blog they use to attack each other on. Please tell me your smart enough to figure this out? Formerres seems to be egging on a situation and not only one case but 2? I am sure he is one of the parties involved in this case as well... It would be a shame that they are using this blog as a way to communicate in a negative behavior... you may want to monitor that, before this spins way out of control. This seems to be "hate" blogging...
justice? March 25, 2011 at 02:42 am
Your policy states:
1. is defamatory, abusive, obscene, profane or offensive; 2. violates any party’s right of publicity or right of privacy; 3. is threatening, harassing or that promotes racism, bigotry, hatred or physical harm of any kind against any group or individual; 4. promotes or encourages violence <---- I think this may be right on the money on some of these posts...
Tomthumb April 22, 2011 at 11:36 pm
I am amazed at some of the comments some of these people have expressed. I happen to know several of these young adults, who were charged with these criminal activities. The ones I know personally are not angels by any means. Most people would call them trouble-making insecure punks. They are slowly heading towards big trouble and unfortunately that may very well mean disturbing problems for all who come into their path. Two of them are very well known as not only drug users, but drug pushers. One of their girl-friends told me that me that one of the guys said, "my lawyer has everything under control. nothing is going to happen to me". I do hope justice is truly served, because if it is not, these punks will not have learned anything. My child was at the party and said they were not invited guests and were asked to leave. They left, decided to come back with some other people and a bunch of weapons and did so. People were stabbed and hit. fortunately, no one was killed. Their friends who have have posted on this site seem to be illiterate. Defending their friends tells you a lot about what kind of people they are.
Tomthumb April 22, 2011 at 11:52 pm
I know that the guy arrested from Northport is a drug dealer. How do I know? Because I have bought drugs from him. I'm not saying that is right. Several of these guys came across to me as just wannabees. They lift some weights and do some juice to make themselves think they look bad. Actually they look pretty lousy for weightlifters who juice. They carry themselves like they think they are bad-asses. We will see how bad they are when they are separated from their little evil support group and have to spend(hopefully) some time where they belong with the other dirtbags. Even though I smoke a little pot and have tried a little coke, I could never have done anything like that.
andre Klitchko April 23, 2011 at 05:24 am
You just said your child was at that party right? and then in the next paragraph you said youu bought drugs from one of them, am i right or wrong but who looks like the dirtbag your supposed to be a parent and you are buying drugs from people 30 years younger then you?
Kelly Campbell April 23, 2011 at 12:31 pm
You might be correct here. I'll review them this weekend. Thanks very much. Kelly
Irene April 23, 2011 at 01:34 pm
People were severely injured enough to require hospitalization. Crimes were committed. The parents and homeowner who was out of town must be mortified about the whole thing. Think about it. Your child has a New Year’s Eve party and kids have to go to the hospital. Thank God no one died. I am sure the legal problems for the parents will not go away too fast as well. As parents we all need tougher oversight with our children. What were they thinking leaving a 19 year old home alone on New Year’s? Did they think the kids were going to play Scrabble? Good kids or not they are kids and underage kids for that matter. Hope everyone heals. Parents, stay on top of your kids.
Kelly Campbell April 23, 2011 at 01:56 pm
Agreed. Even though legally a 19-year-old is an adult, I know that many still don't have the decision-making skills necessary to do the right thing. I know for sure that as a 19-year-old, almost three decades ago,I would have had a party with or without my parents' permission if they were away on New Year's Eve. I still had that feeling of invincibility and that nothing bad would go wrong. Right, Mom?
Irene April 23, 2011 at 02:15 pm
The drinking age is 21. I do not know if there were children at the home who were not even 18. My point is what parent would think that this could ever have been a "good idea"? 40 miles away while if you like, young adults (19) have a New Year's Eve party. The parents thinking precess must come in to play somewhere here. Agreed?
Kelly Campbell April 23, 2011 at 04:31 pm
Well, I have heard from many that they feel it may not have been the best idea. I'm sure they learned a valuable lesson. Hopefully we all learned one along with them. I know many parents who feel it's okay for their kids to drink. Some even supply them with the alcohol. Some have the attitude that they are going to do it anyway — and this does appear to have some validity — so it may as well be in the safety of their home.
Irene April 23, 2011 at 07:32 pm
Kelly you miss the point. There was no adult supervision. 19 year olds were in charge. Why do you think the drinking age was moved to 21? Teens make bad choices. Worse choices when no one is watching. I guess I am out of touch. We reap what we sow. I f most of you think this was really no big deal I stand corrected.
Bob April 24, 2011 at 04:29 am
Irene you are right about it not being a good idea for the parents to leave the 19 year old home alone on New Years Eve, I for one do not leave my teens home alone overnight. But I am sure that they did not ever think that kids from our neighborhood would act like "thugs" and commit such a crime at their home. And TOMTHUMB what makes you any better than the "punks" charged in this case? Buying drugs from them and using drugs, what kind of role model are you for your own child? People can't point fingers and say they are druggies and dealers when you are purchasing from them. I do agree that the charged should serve some time for their actions and hooefully learn from it. No punishment for stabbing people and intentionally returning to cause harm would be a joke!
Jean May 3, 2011 at 04:45 pm
Any word on how the Court appeances went today?
elizabeth May 21, 2011 at 10:53 pm
omg thats so bad
Jean May 22, 2011 at 03:46 pm
Anthony you sound like a real upstanding citizen, being happy that someone got stabbed, check your values and morals.
Mikey June 29, 2011 at 02:28 am
whats going on with the case??? Are they getting jail tim at least?
Jean June 29, 2011 at 02:42 am
I heard that they are not getting jail time, maybe probation if anything. Don't know for sure though.
Jacky August 8, 2011 at 05:02 pm
Guess this story was all false, Because if this stuff was true these kids would not be getting off this easy especially with priors Like you said and some of them already have been to jail, so at the end of all this charged with two misdemeadors
Steve B December 29, 2011 at 06:36 pm
Im from this town, and i Know all the Kids involved, and all of them are a bit Hot Headed, no one Should Have to Experiance Jail, but Things like this will Get you there Quick, i was looking threw the top 10 Criminal stories in NP and Im sad to say i Went to School or have met personally 8 out of 10 of the stories. And almost all of these incidences, were involving Heavy Drug use, and or Alcohol, What ever happened to just having fun
Beetch January 22, 2012 at 06:34 am
KELLY GET A REAL JOB
TheColdHardTruth August 4, 2012 at 02:40 am
Kelly you do a great job. You're intelligent, articulate, and beautiful. Keep up the good work. Listen guys, the bottom line to this story is that these "Savocchi" boys and the others that were with them are white trash. They have a bad reputation in Northport. I've only lived here for about 8 years and I've heard about them numerous times. These losers are going no where in life, we can only hope they'll move away because it is clear that their parents never taught them anything or raised them with any real values. They are trash, and in Northport we need to get rid of the trash. As if being criminals and not liked wasn't bad enough, those boys in that crew are all ugly as hell :) Lastly, the Femianos are an incredibly respected family in this community and it's a shame that they had to deal with these losers causing ruckus at their place. And that's the bottom line.
Mikey October 23, 2012 at 07:01 am
TheColdHardTruth Is these kids beat an attempted murder charge and got a slap on the wrist Thts what happens when You pay a Lawyer, Dont Blame The People Getting rich Blame The kids Abusing and Buying the drugs Violence will never stop, And Lets Get one thing Straight Nothings lower then Being a Snitch U get Stabbed Suck it up and get the Kids back dont Go running to the cops And P.S the Savocchi's are Puerto rican And Italian....White Trash? And as Far as the 5 kids go I think there all doing good And Are working At Well Paid Jobs (:
Chris December 18, 2012 at 06:26 am
'Nothings worse than bein a snitch U get Stabbed Suck it up and get the Kids back'???? are you retarded. I mean come on grow up. Do you have any values or do you want kids gettin stabbed left and right. I mean I heard that the reason all this happened was cause the other kids continuously beat the crap out of savocchi and the only leg up they had was weapons. Settling things with fists is ok once weapons are involved its over. Also I heard the dumb kids they are went to the same hospital so of course they were gonna get pinched. It wasn't snitchin and we also don't live in the ghetto u idiot.
Chris December 18, 2012 at 06:30 am
I mean that was for real you don't go stabbing kids in Northport grow up and realize that you don't live in the ghetto

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Northport Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something